The Window That Closes Before You Notice
The best time to ask for a review is not when you remember to do it. It's when the client is still emotionally connected to the outcome you delivered. That window is shorter than most brokers think. Ask too early and the client hasn't experienced the full benefit yet. Ask too late and the emotion has faded into routine. The difference between these moments can determine whether you get a glowing testimonial or a polite decline.
Consider a broker who settles a first home buyer on a Tuesday and sends a review request the following Monday. The client has spent the weekend moving boxes, arguing about furniture placement, and discovering that the hot water system makes a weird noise. The excitement of settlement has been replaced by the reality of home ownership. The review that comes back, if it comes at all, is functional rather than enthusiastic. The same request sent on settlement day, while the client is still holding the keys and texting photos to family, generates something completely different.
Settlement Day vs Two Weeks Later
Requesting a review on settlement day captures the emotional peak. Clients are relieved, excited, and genuinely grateful in that moment. The process is still fresh enough that they can articulate what you did well, but the outcome is tangible enough that they're not speculating about whether it was worth it. Waiting two weeks means you're asking them to recreate that feeling from memory, which most people can't or won't do.
The practical issue is that most brokers are already managing the next client by settlement day and the review request feels like one more administrative task. That's exactly why it needs to be automated. A system that triggers a review request within 24 hours of settlement doesn't rely on you remembering or having capacity. It just happens. The brokers who convert the most website visitors into enquiries are the ones with recent, specific, enthusiastic reviews sitting at the top of their reviews page, and those reviews come from settlement-day requests, not follow-up emails sent weeks later.
Not sure how your website compares?
Get a free Website Report and find out in seconds where you can improve
The Refinance Timing Problem
Refinance clients operate on a different timeline. The emotional peak isn't settlement, it's the moment they see the new interest rate confirmed or the first lower repayment come out of their account. That might be a week after settlement, or it might be a month, depending on how quickly the new lender processes the first payment cycle. Asking for a review at settlement when the client hasn't yet experienced the financial benefit you promised is premature. They'll agree in principle that you did a good job, but the review will lack the specificity that makes it credible to someone reading it on your website.
In our experience, the refinance clients who leave the most useful reviews are the ones who've had at least one full payment cycle under the new loan. They can say exactly how much they're saving, and they've had time to appreciate that the process was smoother than they expected. That's the review that converts a website visitor who's comparing brokers. Timing the request to land after that first payment, rather than immediately after settlement, is the difference between a testimonial that says "great service" and one that says "saved $620 a month and the whole thing took three weeks."
First Home Buyers Need a Different Approach
First home buyers are emotionally invested from day one, but the peak moment isn't always settlement. For some, it's the pre-approval. For others, it's the moment the building inspection comes back clean and they know the purchase is really happening. The strongest reviews from first home buyers tend to come when you ask twice: once after pre-approval if the process was particularly smooth or fast, and again after settlement. The first request captures the relief and excitement of knowing they can actually buy. The second captures the full journey. Not every client will leave two reviews, but giving them the option means you don't miss the moment when they're most motivated.
The mistake is assuming all first home buyers feel the same way at settlement. Some are exhausted and overwhelmed. Others are elated. If your review request is timed purely to settlement, you're gambling on which emotional state they're in. A better approach is to send a brief message on settlement day thanking them and letting them know a review request is coming in a few days, then follow up when they've had time to settle in. That second request, sent three to five days post-settlement, tends to generate more thoughtful responses because the client has had time to reflect without losing the emotional connection.
The Sequence That Actually Works
The most effective review request timing isn't a single email. It's a sequence that acknowledges where the client is in their journey. Settlement day gets a thank you message with no ask. Three days later, the review request arrives with a direct link and a reminder of what you helped them achieve. If they don't respond within a week, a single follow-up message that acknowledges they're probably busy and offers to make it easier by suggesting a phone call instead. Most brokers stop at the first request and assume the client isn't interested. In reality, they're just busy, and a well-timed follow-up is often all it takes.
This sequence works because it respects the client's time while making it clear that their feedback matters. It also increases the chance that the review is written when the client has something specific to say, rather than when they're rushing through their inbox. The brokers who consistently capture high-quality reviews are the ones who've automated this sequence so it runs without manual intervention. That automation is part of what separates a high-conversion website from one that just looks good. If you're building or upgrading your site, make sure your review system can handle sequenced requests, not just one-off emails.
Call one of our team or book an appointment at a time that works for you. We'll walk through how review request timing integrates with the rest of your website strategy and show you what a properly optimised system looks like in practice.
Frequently Asked Questions
When is the best time to ask a client for a review after settlement?
The best time is within 24 hours of settlement for most clients, when they're still emotionally connected to the outcome. For refinance clients, waiting until after their first payment cycle under the new loan often generates more specific and useful reviews.
Should I send a review request on settlement day or wait a few weeks?
Send it on settlement day or within 24 hours. Waiting two weeks means the emotional peak has passed and clients are less likely to respond with enthusiasm. Automate the request so it happens consistently without relying on manual follow-up.
Why do first home buyers need a different review request approach?
First home buyers experience emotional peaks at different stages, including pre-approval and settlement. Sending a thank you on settlement day followed by the review request three to five days later gives them time to reflect without losing the emotional connection.
How many times should I follow up if a client doesn't respond to a review request?
One follow-up message is appropriate, sent about a week after the initial request. Acknowledge they're busy and offer an easier option like a phone call. Most clients aren't ignoring you, they're just overwhelmed.
What makes a review request sequence more effective than a single email?
A sequence respects the client's timing and increases the chance they respond when they have something specific to say. Starting with a thank you, followed by the request, then a single follow-up, generates more high-quality reviews than one-off emails.
