Conversion tracking tells you which visitors became enquiries and where they came from. Without it, you are guessing whether your website is working.
Some brokers know how many people visit their site but not how many get in touch. This guide is for brokers who have a website, or are about to build one, and want to know what to measure first.
What Is Conversion Tracking on a Broker Website?
Conversion tracking records the actions that matter to your business, such as a form submission, a click on your phone number or a booked appointment. It links each action back to the source, like a Google search or a social post.
For a broker, a conversion is not a page view. It is a person raising their hand. A visitor who reads three blog posts and leaves has not converted. A visitor who taps your phone number has.
You set this up with tools from Google that carry no licence fee, usually Google Analytics and Google Search Console, plus a tag manager if you want more control. Your web developer can install these when the site is built, which is far less work than adding them later.
Which Actions Should You Measure First?
Start with three actions that show clear intent to talk to a broker: phone clicks, enquiry form submissions and booked calls. Everything else is secondary until those are recorded properly.
If you want to go further, add smaller signals, such as clicks on a loan calculator or downloads of a guide. These show interest but are not enquiries, so keep them separate in your reports. Mixing them together makes your numbers look healthier than they are.
One trade-off to know about: the more actions you measure, the harder the reports are to read. Pick a short list and stick with it.
How SEO and Conversion Tracking Work Together
SEO brings people to your site, and conversion tracking shows whether those people were the right ones. Ranking well for a search is only useful if the visitors it brings go on to contact you.
That is why a good SEO for mortgage brokers plan looks at enquiries, not just rankings. A page that ranks well but never produces a call may need clearer content or a stronger next step. A page with modest visits that regularly produces enquiries is worth building on.
Local searches are a good example. Local searches may show stronger intent, so it is worth tracking how these pages perform. Our guide to local SEO for mortgage brokers covers how to set those pages up.
Not sure how your website compares?
Get a free Website Report and find out in seconds where you can improve
A Worked Example: Finding the Page That Was Quietly Working
Consider a broker whose site gets a few hundred visits a month. They assume the home page is doing most of the work, because it gets the most traffic. Their only measure of success is the total visitor count, and they are thinking about paying for a full redesign.
After setting up conversion tracking, they see something different. Most form submissions come from a single blog post about first home buyer steps, and almost none come from the home page. The home page has no clear next step, while the blog post ends with a prominent enquiry form.
Instead of a redesign, they add a clear enquiry button and short form to the home page, and link their other helpful articles to the booking page. Over the next few months, the reports show more enquiries coming from the home page and from several of the other posts. The number of visitors barely changes, but the number of people getting in touch does.
The point is that tracking showed them where to put their effort. The figures in this scenario are illustrative only, and results will differ for every site.
Why Your Call to Action Decides What You Measure
A conversion can only be recorded if your page asks for one. Every important page needs one clear next step, such as booking a call, and that step needs to be obvious to spot and to measure.
Vague buttons like "Submit" give visitors little reason to act. Wording that matches what the visitor wants, such as "Book a call about my home loan", tends to feel more relevant. Our call to action strategy page explains how to choose and place these.
The trade-off is that too many options on one page can split attention. One main action with a quieter second option is usually enough.
What to Check Each Month Without Getting Lost in Reports
A short monthly review is enough: look at total enquiries, the pages they came from and the search or channel that sent the visitor. Then ask what to change on one or two pages.
This habit matters more than the tool you use. Reviewing the same few numbers each month lets you spot patterns, like a page that suddenly stops producing enquiries after an edit. It also gives you facts to use when deciding whether to invest in more content or in lead generation.
Keep in mind that small numbers can mislead. If your site only gets a handful of enquiries each month, a single extra call can look like a big change. Look at several months together before making large decisions.
Setting Up Tracking When You Build or Upgrade Your Site
The most cost-effective time to set up tracking is during the build, when forms, buttons and phone links can be tagged from day one. Adding it later is possible but often means reworking pages.
A purpose-built mortgage broker website design should include conversion tracking in its scope, with a clear list of which actions are recorded. Ask who owns the Google accounts, so you keep access if you ever change providers.
Privacy also matters. If you collect personal details through forms, your site should have a clear privacy policy and you should handle the information appropriately. Check your obligations with a qualified adviser.
Book a call with the Broker Studio team and we will walk you through what to measure on your site and how to set it up.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is conversion tracking on a broker website?
It records actions such as phone clicks, form submissions and booked calls, and links them to where the visitor came from. This shows which pages and searches lead to real enquiries.
Which actions should a broker measure first?
Start with phone clicks, enquiry form submissions and booked calls. Add smaller signals later, but report them separately so they do not inflate your results.
How does SEO relate to conversion tracking?
SEO brings visitors to your site, and tracking shows whether those visitors get in touch. Together they show which pages are worth improving or expanding.
When should tracking be set up?
Ideally during the website build, when forms and buttons can be tagged from the start. Adding it later is possible but can mean reworking pages.