CTA Button Design Mistakes That Kill Mortgage Broker Leads

Transform your website's conversion rate with professional CTA button design strategies that turn visitors into clients

Hero Image for CTA Button Design Mistakes That Kill Mortgage Broker Leads

Your website might be attracting visitors, but are they becoming clients? The difference often lies in your call-to-action buttons. These small yet powerful elements can make or break your lead generation efforts. For mortgage brokers, every missed opportunity represents potential commission lost.

The Psychology Behind Effective CTA Buttons

Successful CTA button design goes beyond aesthetics. It's about understanding what motivates your visitors to take action. Mortgage brokers need buttons that create urgency whilst building trust. Your potential clients are making significant financial decisions, so your CTAs must inspire confidence.

Effective buttons use action-oriented language that speaks directly to your audience's needs. Instead of generic phrases like "Click here" or "Submit", try "Get My Free Home Loan Assessment" or "Schedule My Consultation Today". This approach transforms a simple click into a valuable exchange.

Essential Design Elements for High-Conversion CTA Buttons

The visual design of your CTA buttons significantly impacts their performance. Here are the key elements that drive results:

  1. Colour contrast - Your button should stand out from your website's colour scheme whilst maintaining professional appearance
  2. Size and spacing - Large enough to be easily clickable on mobile devices, with adequate white space around them
  3. Typography - Bold, readable fonts that match your brand's professional image
  4. Shape and style - Rounded corners often perform better than sharp edges, creating a more approachable feel

Your call to action strategy should align with your overall website design whilst ensuring maximum visibility and engagement.

Not sure how your website compares?

Get a free Website Report and find out in seconds where you can improve

Placement Strategies That Generate More Leads

Where you position your CTA buttons is just as important as how they look. Strategic placement ensures maximum visibility without overwhelming your visitors. Consider these prime locations:

  • Above the fold on your homepage
  • At the end of service descriptions
  • Within testimonial sections
  • On your contact and about pages
  • Throughout your blog articles

For mortgage brokers, placing CTAs near trust indicators like testimonials, industry certifications, or client success stories can significantly boost conversion rates. This positioning reinforces your credibility at the moment visitors are deciding whether to engage.

Mobile Optimisation for CTA Success

With most Australians browsing on mobile devices, your CTA buttons must work flawlessly across all screen sizes. Mobile-optimised buttons should be:

  • Large enough for thumb navigation (minimum 44px height)
  • Positioned away from other clickable elements
  • Fast-loading and responsive
  • Easy to tap without zooming

Poor mobile CTA design can cost you significant leads. When considering a website upgrade, mobile CTA optimisation should be a priority.

Testing and Improving Your CTA Performance

Creating effective CTAs isn't a one-time task. Continuous testing and refinement are essential for maintaining high conversion rates. Monitor which buttons generate the most leads and which pages perform best.

Key metrics to evaluate include:

  • Click-through rates on different button colours
  • Conversion rates from various page locations
  • Mobile versus desktop performance
  • Response to different button text variations

Regular analysis helps identify opportunities for improvement and ensures your professional website development continues delivering results.

Common CTA Mistakes Mortgage Brokers Make

Many mortgage broker websites struggle with CTA effectiveness due to common design errors:

  • Using too many competing CTAs on one page
  • Choosing colours that blend into the background
  • Writing vague or generic button text
  • Making buttons too small or difficult to find
  • Forgetting to optimise for mobile users

Avoiding these mistakes whilst implementing proven website design principles can dramatically improve your lead generation results.

Building Trust Through CTA Design

Mortgage brokers handle sensitive financial information, making trust crucial for conversion success. Your CTA design should reinforce your professional credibility. Use security badges near contact forms, include privacy assurances, and ensure your buttons lead to secure, professional pages.

Consider adding trust elements like "No obligation consultation" or "Free confidential assessment" to reduce visitor hesitation. These additions can significantly improve conversion rates by addressing common concerns upfront.

Effective CTA button design is fundamental to high-conversion websites that generate consistent leads. By implementing these strategies, you'll create a more engaging user experience that converts more visitors into valuable clients.

Ready to transform your website's conversion potential? Your current CTA buttons might be costing you clients every day. Call one of our team or book an appointment at a time that works for you to discuss how professional website design can boost your lead generation results.


Need help getting your website working properly?

Our experts can give you a free website review and help you improve