Your website visitors know they need help with finance, but most of them leave without making contact because you haven't made it clear what they should do next.
A call to action is the specific prompt that tells visitors how to take the next step with you. For finance brokers, the right call to action strategy determines whether someone clicks through to book a call or closes the tab and moves on to another broker. The difference between a website that generates leads and one that just looks professional comes down to using the right types of call-to-actions in the right places.
Primary Call-to-Actions: The Main Conversion Point
A primary call to action is the single most important action you want visitors to take on any given page. For most mortgage brokers, this is booking a discovery call or submitting a contact form. This button or link appears prominently above the fold and is repeated at strategic points as visitors scroll.
Consider a broker who had a website with a generic "Contact Us" button in the navigation. After switching to a bold "Book Your Free Strategy Call" button positioned directly below their headline, they saw enquiries increase by 40% within the first month. The action stayed the same, but the language shifted from passive to specific. Visitors knew exactly what would happen when they clicked: a free call focused on strategy, not a sales pitch.
Your primary call to action needs to appear within the first screen of every key page. On your homepage, it belongs immediately after your value proposition. On service pages, place it after you've explained the problem you solve but before you lose their attention to detail. The button colour should contrast with your site design, and the text should describe the outcome rather than the action. "Get Pre-Approved in 24 Hours" performs better than "Submit Form" because it focuses on what the visitor gains.
Secondary Call-to-Actions for Different Readiness Levels
A secondary call to action offers an alternative option for visitors who aren't ready for the primary commitment. Someone researching first home buyer options might not be ready to book a call, but they'll download a checklist or use a borrowing calculator. These lower-commitment actions keep them engaged and capture their contact details for follow-up.
Effective secondary options for finance brokers include downloadable guides, calculators, email courses, or quick quote forms. Place these alongside your primary call to action or use them on pages where visitors are still in research mode. A blog article about improving your ranking on google might include a primary call to action for SEO services and a secondary option to download a website audit checklist.
The key is matching the offer to where visitors are in their decision process. Someone reading about refinancing is further along than someone just exploring options. Your service pages should lean heavily on primary actions, while educational content can rely more on secondary captures that build trust before pushing for a booking.
Exit-Intent Call-to-Actions That Catch Leaving Visitors
An exit-intent call to action appears when someone moves their cursor toward closing the tab or navigating away from your site. This popup or overlay offers one final chance to capture their attention before they leave. For mortgage brokers, this works best when offering something immediately valuable rather than repeating your standard booking request.
A broker running exit-intent popups found that offering a free borrowing capacity calculator generated a 12% capture rate on visitors who were about to leave. The same popup asking people to book a call generated less than 3%. Visitors leaving your site aren't ready for commitment, but they'll exchange an email address for a tool that helps them right now.
Keep exit-intent offers simple and fast to access. A five-field form asking for employment details and income figures creates friction. A single email field that delivers an instant calculator or PDF guide works better. You can follow up via email to move them toward booking, but the exit popup needs to feel like a quick win rather than another sales step.
Not sure how your website compares?
Get a free Website Report and find out in seconds where you can improve
Inline Call-to-Actions Within Content
Inline call-to-actions appear naturally within your content rather than standing alone as buttons. These might be hyperlinked text prompting visitors to explore a related service, book a specific type of appointment, or access a tool. They work particularly well in blog articles and educational pages where a standalone button feels too aggressive.
When writing about first home buyer grants, you might include a line like "if you're ready to see how much you can borrow with these grants included, book a free discovery call to run the numbers together." The call to action flows from the content itself rather than interrupting it. Visitors who are genuinely interested click through, while others keep reading without feeling pushed.
For finance brokers building content-rich websites, inline actions turn educational material into lead generation assets. A visitor reading about loan structures might not respond to a button at the bottom of the page, but they'll click a contextual link when you explain a complex scenario and offer to work through their specific numbers. These actions feel helpful rather than promotional because they appear exactly when the visitor has a question you can answer.
Sticky Call-to-Actions That Follow Scroll Behaviour
A sticky call to action remains visible as visitors scroll down the page, typically fixed to the bottom of the screen or floating in a corner. This keeps your primary action accessible without forcing visitors to scroll back to the top when they're ready to convert. For longer service pages or detailed articles, sticky actions ensure you don't lose someone who's convinced halfway down the page.
Brokers using sticky call-to-actions on their service pages report higher conversion rates because the barrier to action drops. A visitor reading about commercial finance services might be ready to book after the third section, but if they have to scroll back up to find the button, some won't bother. A sticky "Book Commercial Finance Call" button removes that friction entirely.
Keep sticky actions compact so they don't block content on mobile devices. A thin bar across the bottom with a single button works better than a large overlay that covers a quarter of the screen. The goal is persistent visibility without annoyance. If visitors start closing your sticky bar repeatedly, it's too intrusive and needs redesigning.
Conversational Call-to-Actions via Chat Widgets
Conversational call-to-actions appear through live chat widgets or chatbots that invite visitors to ask questions. These work well for finance brokers because they lower the commitment threshold even further than a form. Someone uncertain about booking a full call might type a quick question, which opens a conversation that leads to booking.
The most effective chat prompts are specific rather than generic. "Got a question about refinancing?" performs better than "How can we help?" because it acknowledges what the visitor is likely researching. You can trigger different prompts based on which page someone is viewing: a question about asset finance on equipment pages, a question about pre-approval on first home buyer pages.
Whether you use live chat or automated responses, the goal is the same: start a conversation that moves toward booking. Even a simple chatbot that answers three common questions and then prompts "Want to discuss your specific situation? Book a call here" converts better than no interaction at all. Just make sure responses feel human, not scripted, and align with the warm, direct tone visitors expect from a professional broker.
The call-to-actions you choose and where you place them determines whether your website generates consistent leads or just sits there looking professional. Most brokers default to a single "Contact" button and wonder why enquiries stay flat. Using a mix of primary, secondary, exit-intent, inline, sticky, and conversational actions gives every visitor a clear path forward, no matter where they are in their decision process.
If your current website isn't converting visitors into clients, your call to action strategy likely needs a rebuild. Call one of our team or book an appointment at a time that works for you to talk through what's missing and how to fix it.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a primary call-to-action for a mortgage broker website?
A primary call-to-action is the single most important action you want visitors to take on a page, typically booking a discovery call or submitting a contact form. It should appear prominently above the fold and use specific language that describes the outcome, like 'Book Your Free Strategy Call' rather than generic text like 'Contact Us'.
When should I use a secondary call-to-action instead of a primary one?
Use secondary call-to-actions for visitors who aren't ready to book a call yet, offering lower-commitment options like downloadable guides, calculators, or quick quote forms. These work best on educational content where visitors are still researching, while primary actions belong on service pages where visitors are closer to making a decision.
Do exit-intent popups actually work for mortgage brokers?
Exit-intent popups work when they offer immediate value rather than repeating your standard booking request. A popup offering a free borrowing capacity calculator or downloadable guide captures leaving visitors far more effectively than asking them to book a call they've already decided against.
Where should I place call-to-actions on my mortgage broker website?
Place your primary call-to-action above the fold on every key page and repeat it after important sections. Use inline actions within content where they flow naturally, add sticky actions on longer pages so the button follows as visitors scroll, and include exit-intent offers for people about to leave.
What makes a call-to-action button convert better?
Effective call-to-action buttons use specific language that describes the outcome rather than the action, like 'Get Pre-Approved in 24 Hours' instead of 'Submit Form'. The button should contrast visually with your site design and appear exactly when visitors are ready to take the next step, not buried at the bottom of a long page.
